Legislation Details

File #: 700   
Type: Discussion Status: Passed
File created: 7/16/2019 Department: Public Works-Solid Waste Management
On agenda: 7/23/2019 Final action: 7/23/2019
Subject: Public Hearing for the Collection of Delinquent Solid Waste Handling Fees
Attachments: 1. ATT-PW-Waste 7-23-19 Public Hearing on Delinquent Solid Waste Handling Fees, 2. PH-PW-Waste 7-23-19 Delinquent SW Hauler Fees.pdf, 3. Item #54 Executed BAI

REPORT/RECOMMENDATION TO THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS

OF THE COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO

AND RECORD OF ACTION

 

July 23, 2019

 

FROM

KEVIN BLAKESLEE, Director, Department of Public Works - Solid Waste Management 

         

SUBJECT                      

Title                     

Public Hearing for the Collection of Delinquent Solid Waste Handling Fees

End

 

RECOMMENDATION(S)

Recommendation

CONTINUED OPEN HEARING FROM JULY 9, 2019, ITEM NO. 59

1.                     Conduct a public hearing regarding placement of franchise hauler identified delinquent solid waste handling service fees on the property tax assessment roll.

2.                     Adopt the report of delinquent fees on file with the Clerk of the Board.

3.                     Authorize the Director of Public Works to amend the report of delinquent fees to remove those accounts that are paid in full, or adjust the amounts owed due to the revision of the penalties and the fees and/or partial payment of the delinquent charges, prior to the report being submitted to the Auditor-Controller/Treasurer/Tax Collector for placement on the 2019 property tax roll and to the Assessor-Recorder-County Clerk for the recording of liens against the parcels.

(Presenter: Kevin Blakeslee, Director, 387-7906)

Body

 

COUNTY AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER GOALS & OBJECTIVES

Operate in a Fiscally-Responsible and Business-Like Manner.

 

FINANCIAL IMPACT

Approval of this item will not result in the use of Discretionary General Funding (Net County Cost) as the Department of Public Works - Solid Waste Management Division (SWMD) is financed by fee revenue. SWMD established fees that are charged to the public and other agencies for utilization of the County Waste Disposal System. The franchise haulers have reported an estimated 5,721 delinquent accounts, totaling $1,705,348.70 in unpaid service charges and related lien processing fees, for proposed placement on the 2019 property tax roll for the 2019-20 Budget Year. As authorized by the County Code, SWMD charges a penalty fee of 10% of the unpaid service charges, which is included in the delinquent accounts total, for performing this task on behalf of the franchise haulers.

 

BACKGROUND INFORMATION

On April 6, 2004 (Item No. 21), the Board of Supervisors (Board) approved Uniform Handling Services in the valley and a portion of the mountain unincorporated area of the County requiring all improved residential properties to participate in mandatory trash collection service. Uniform Handling property owners have the option of obtaining an approved exemption from trash and recycling collection service by obtaining a Uniform Handling Exemption after meeting the specific criteria of the program.

 

In areas subject to Uniform Handling, the County Code and franchise agreements prohibit the hauler from discontinuing service for non-payment of monthly service fees. County Code section 46.0506 provides that monthly service charges become delinquent if unpaid for 90 days after the invoice is mailed. In order to compensate the franchise hauler for services provided, the County Code Section 46.0506 provides that the unpaid charges become a debt owed to the County that can be collected through the County’s property tax roll and is then reimbursed to the franchise hauler. The number of liens and the amount collected for previous years is demonstrated in the following table:

 

Budget Year

Liens Authorized

Liens Placed

Collected

 

Number

Amount

Number

Amount

Amount*

2018-19

5,093

$1,449,351

3,419

$1,078,485

$1,022,956

2017-18

4,870

$1,393,490

3,058

$998,920

$946,851

2016-17

4,581

$1,380.976

2,882

$981,503

$922,168

2015-16

5,329

$1,445,267

3,443

$1,070,236

$1,072,419

2014-15

5,160

$1,370,396

3,457

$1,029,989

$1,056,541

2013-14

5,490

$1,417,829

3,600

$1,034,817

$1,089,236

2012-13

5,706

$1,435,902

4,017

$1,087,916

$1,115,752

*Includes delinquent charges, administrative costs, and interest and penalties.

 

The final number of liens to be placed on the tax roll each year are less than the number authorized because customers are afforded the opportunity to pay, in full or in part, their delinquent charges prior to the recordation of a lien against the parcel. Customers that have an outstanding balance are notified by the franchise haulers through the regular billing process.  In addition, prior to the Public Hearing, on June 21, 2019, the haulers mailed a letter to the customers notifying them of their Delinquent Trash and Recycling Service Charges and of the possibility that a lien may be placed on their property if payment is not received. The letter provides customers with the date, time and location of this public hearing and a final date to receive payment in order to avoid additional fees and having a lien recorded against their property.

 

For the 2019 tax roll, there are an estimated 5,721 delinquent accounts for service charges and related lien processing fees totaling $1,705,348.70 in the following County Franchise Areas:

 

County Franchise Area

Number of Liens

Delinquent Amount including fees

Location

Franchise Hauler

CFA 1

76

$23,745.05

San Antonio Heights, Mt. Baldy

Burrtec Waste Industries

CFA 2

184

$58,078.34

Unincorporated Montclair, Upland

Burrtec Waste Industries

CFA 5

865

$276,581.87

Unincorporated West Fontana

Burrtec Waste Industries

CFA 6

754

$234,252.75

Bloomington

Burrtec Waste Industries

CFA 8

583

$198,932.12

Muscoy, Unincorporated San Bernardino

Cal Disposal

CFA 9

71

$25,182.87

Unincorporated North Rialto

Burrtec Waste Industries

CFA 10

854

$268,404.55

Del Rosa, Devore

Jack’s Disposal

CFA 11

15

$4,007.26

Unincorporated Loma Linda

Burrtec Waste Industries

CFA 12

245

$82,260.42

Mentone, Oak Glen, Angelus Oaks, Mountain Home

Empire Disposal

CFA 16

2,074

$533,903.47

Lake Arrowhead, Crestline, Running Springs

Mountain Disposal Company

Total

5,721

$1,705,348.70

 

 

 

Section 5473 et seq. of the California Health and Safety Code sets forth the procedures for collecting such delinquent fees through the tax roll. The statute requires the scheduling of a public hearing to accept the list of delinquent charges as a debt owed to the County and that all affected property owners be notified of the hearing at least 14 days prior to the scheduled date of the hearing. This was accomplished by the Clerk of the Board through publishing notice in local newspapers. In addition, the franchise haulers were directed to mail a written notice of the time, date, and location of said hearing to all affected property owners within their respective franchise areas.

 

Upon submittal to the Auditor-Controller/Treasurer/Tax Collector and Assessor-Recorder-County Clerk, the delinquent accounts will be placed on the tax rolls for collection and liens recorded against the applicable parcels in accordance with Code Section 46.0506. The recorded liens will provide notice to subsequent purchasers and mortgagees of the outstanding delinquencies. Collecting delinquent hauler service charges through the tax rolls is a standard practice for local jurisdictions such as the cities of Fontana, Yucaipa, Rialto, Highland, and many others that provide their communities with similar Uniform Handling services. The County first placed delinquent hauler liens on the 2005 tax roll for Budget Year 2005-06. This practice assists the County in meeting its obligation to provide solid waste handling services as required in Public Resource Code Section 40057 and in meeting the requirements of Assembly Bill 939 (1989).

 

The placement and collection of delinquent hauler fees on the property tax assessment role supports the goals and objectives of operating in a fiscally-responsible and business-like manner by taking all necessary steps to ensure that property owners who are required to pay for solid waste collection services do so.

 

Dialogue is underway with representatives from Mountain Disposal Company (Burrtec) regarding the implementation of a new Fee Waiver program that would replace the previous program discontinued by the County Franchise Area (CFA) 16 franchise hauler in late 2017.  Currently the details of this program are still being worked out. The County Administrative Office and Department of Public Works staff intend to continue engaging in these discussions with the goal of returning with an amendment to the franchise agreement for CFA 16 for the Board’s approval on a future board agenda.

 

The County continues to offer a self-haul Exemption Program, separate from the franchise hauler’s Fee Waiver program mentioned above, that is geared to full-time residents of the County areas who prefer to self-haul their waste to an approved solid waste facility in lieu of curbside service.  Through the submission of an application, including a small application fee and the inclusion of documentation to demonstrate regular self-haul of trash to an approved solid waste facility, residents are able to gain an exemption from the mandatory trash collection requirement and are thereby exempt from trash collection fees.

 

PROCUREMENT

Not applicable.

 

REVIEW BY OTHERS

This item has been reviewed by County Counsel (Kristina Robb, Deputy County Counsel, 387-5455) on June 12, 2019; Finance (Wen Mai, Administrative Analyst, 387-4020) on June 14, 2019; and County Finance and Administration (Matthew Erickson, County Chief Financial Officer, 387-5423) on June 23, 2019.