REPORT/RECOMMENDATION TO THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
OF SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY
AND RECORD OF ACTION
July 25, 2023
FROM
JASON ANDERSON, District Attorney
SUBJECT
TitleTitle
Software License Agreement with Bosch Automotive Service Solutions, Inc. for Crash Data Retrieval Toolkit
EndEnd
RECOMMENDATION(S)
RecommendationRecommendation
1. Approve the End User License Agreement with Bosch Automotive Service Solutions, Inc., including non-standard terms, for the Crash Data Retrieval Toolkit, effective August 11, 2023, and renewed annually, for a period of five years, ending August 10, 2028.
2. Authorize the District Attorney or the Chief of the Bureau of Investigation to execute the online End User License Agreement for the Crash Data Retrieval Toolkit, on behalf of the County.
3. Authorize the Purchasing Agent to issue Purchase Orders to Crash Data Group, Inc., sole distributor for Bosch Automotive Service Solutions, Inc., for software licensing, hardware upgrades, and training, at a total cost not to exceed $87,500, and to issue future change orders up to $10,000, change non-financial/non-material terms, and sign corresponding non-substantive amendments, subject to County Counsel review.
4. Direct the District Attorney to transmit non-substantive amendments to the End User License Agreement referenced in Recommendation No. 1 to the Clerk of the Board of Supervisors within 30 days of execution.
(Presenter: Michael Fermin, Assistant District Attorney, 382-3662)
BodyBody
COUNTY AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER GOALS & OBJECTIVES8/11
Operate in a Fiscally-Responsible and Business-Like Manner.
Provide for the Safety, Health and Social Service Needs of County Residents.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
Approval of this item will not result in the use of additional Discretionary General Funding (Net County Cost). The hardware for Bosch Automotive Service Solutions, Inc.’s (Bosch) Crash Data Retrieval Toolkit (CDR Toolkit) was purchased in 2018. Total costs for the next five years are estimated at $87,500 for software subscription ($27,500), hardware upgrades ($42,000), and training costs ($18,000). Sufficient appropriation is included within the District Attorney’s (Department) 2023-24 budget and will be included in future recommended budgets.
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
The Department is the public prosecutor and has the mandated responsibility to prosecute crimes committed within San Bernardino County (County) pursuant to Government Code 26500. Law enforcement agencies submit crime reports and investigative information to the Department for review and potential prosecution. Crimes that involve vehicles may require additional investigation to retrieve vehicle forensic information. The types of cases that require vehicle forensic information include vehicular homicide, major injury collision, arson, and auto insurance fraud investigations.
In May 2018, the Department requested a Purchase Order and purchased the CDR Toolkit from the Crash Data Group, Inc., with the software subscription to retrieve and download vehicle forensic information at a cost of $9,700. On June 9, 2020 (Item No. 27), the Board of Supervisors (Board) approved Bosch’s End User License Agreement (EULA) No. 20-384 for the software for a period of three years, which contained non-standard terms. In addition, the Department requested approval of hardware upgrades, and training at a cost not to exceed $25,000. Bosch sets the industry standard in developing this technology and Crash Data Group, Inc. is the reseller who is the sole distributor of the equipment and software.
The CDR Toolkit can download data from most vehicles in North America. The CDR Toolkit retrieves vehicle forensic information that includes changes in velocity, occupancy, seating position, steering input, percentage of braking and throttle being applied by the driver, wheel speed, equipment failure/warning lamps, and the amount and direction of force acting upon the vehicle during a collision. The data recovered can also reveal if the vehicle’s on-board accident avoidance systems were actively engaged prior to and during the collision. This information assists the Department during review of the associated crimes.
The Department requests approval of Bosch’s EULA to continue using the CDR Toolkit. Hardware and software upgrades and staff training will be needed during the term of the EULA as automobile manufacturers improve technology to record more data during collision events. When the Department utilizes the CDR Toolkit to download information, the information is retrieved on-premise, meaning information is not transmitted to, or accessible by, Bosch or the Crash Data Group, Inc. unless the investigator provides permission and access when technical support is required.
The Department also requests that the Board authorize the Purchasing Agent to issue a Purchase Order to Crash Data Group, Inc., sole distributor for Bosch for software licensing, hardware upgrades, and training, at a total cost not to exceed $87,500.
Bosch’s EULA consists of terms and conditions that are not standard to County contract and require approval from the Board. Bosch has taken the position that its EULA terms and conditions are not negotiable. County Counsel has identified the following non-standard terms and conditions:
1. The EULA requires binding arbitration to resolve any dispute or claim arising out of the EULA and venue of the arbitration is in Oakland County, Michigan.
• The County standard contract does not require arbitration.
• Potential Impact: Arbitration decisions are not appealable. In addition, disputes that might otherwise be settled in small claims court would incur arbitration costs that would exceed the costs of a small claims action, and the EULA amount. Having a venue in Oakland County, Michigan may result in additional expenses that exceed the amount of the EULA. County Counsel cannot advise on whether and to what extent such arbitration provisions may be enforceable against a government entity under Michigan law, as County Counsel attorneys are not licensed by the State of Michigan.
2. Bosch disclaims all warranties, express or implied, including the implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose.
• Standard County policy requires a contractor to fully warrant its services and product.
• Potential Impact: The County’s use of the software is solely at its own risk. County Counsel cannot advise on, whether and to what extent, Michigan law may limit or expand the disclaimers of warranty to the extent prohibited by applicable law, as County Counsel attorneys are not licensed by the State of Michigan.
3. Bosch does not provide infringement indemnity to the County in the EULA.
• Standard County policy requires a contractor to provide infringement indemnity or provide a warranty of noninfringement.
• Potential Impact: County Counsel cannot advise as to the enforceability of this provision under Michigan law, as County Counsel attorneys are not licensed by the State of Michigan. Generally speaking, the lack of infringement indemnity increases the County’s potential liability in the event of a third-party lawsuit for intellectual property infringement. The potential disclaimer of a warranty of non-infringement, coupled with the lack of indemnity for intellectual property infringement means that, should the County be sued for intellectual property infringement based on its use of Bosch software, the County will be liable for the costs of defense and damages. While infringement claims against end users are rare, they have been known to occur, and the County could be responsible for defense costs and damages, which could exceed the total EULA amount.
4. The software is provided “As Is” and with all faults. The County’s sole remedy after acceptance of the software is correction of any defects or delivery of a new version of the software, as decided by Bosch.
• Standard County policy requires contractor to fully warrant its services and products.
• Potential Impact: The County’s use of the software is solely at its own risk. County Counsel cannot advise on, whether and to what extent, Michigan law may limit or expand the disclaimers of warranty to the extent prohibited by applicable law, as County Counsel attorneys are not licensed by the State of Michigan.
5. Applicable governing law is that of the State of Michigan.
• Standard County Policy requires the application of California law.
• Potential Impact: The EULA will be interpreted under Michigan law. Any questions, issues or claims arising under this EULA will require the County to hire outside counsel competent to advise on Michigan law, which may result in fees that exceed the total EULA amount.
•
6. The EULA does not require the County’s consent if Bosch elects to assign the EULA.
• Standard County policy states that the County must approve any assignment of the EULA.
• Potential Impact: It appears Bosch has a right to assign the EULA without the County’s consent, Bosch could assign the EULA to a third party or business with which the County is legally prohibited from doing business due to issues of Federal debarment or suspension and conflict of interest, without the County’s knowledge. Should this occur, the County would be out of compliance with the law until it becomes aware of the assignment and terminates the EULA.
7. The EULA does not contain the standard County insurance provisions.
• Standard County policy provides that insurance terms must mirror the insurance provisions in County Standard Policy 11-07.
• Potential Impact: Bosch does not provide any information regarding its current insurance coverage, making it impossible for the County to evaluate the sufficiency of the same. The County has no assurance that BOSCH will be financially responsible for claims that may arise under the EULA, which could result in expenses to the County that exceed the total EULA amount.
8. The EULA states that Bosch shall not be liable for consequential, special or punitive damages.
• Standard County policy provides that a contractor may not limit its liability.
• Potential Impact: This is a limitation of liability. The County will not be able to recover any consequential, special or punitive damages from Bosch. County Counsel cannot advise on, whether and to what extent, Michigan law may limit or expand the exclusion of limits to the extent prohibited by applicable law, as County Counsel attorneys are not licensed by the State of Michigan.
9. The EULA does not contain the standard contract provisions regarding Government Code section 84308 (Senate Bill 1439) and the disclosure of campaign contributions to a member of the Board or other County elected officer.
• Under the County standard contract the contractor states it has disclosed campaign contributions of more than $250 to any member of the Board or other County elected officer and completed a form providing additional information.
• Potential Impact: The County may have difficulty gathering information about campaign contributions made by Bosch.
The Department recommends approval of the terms and conditions of the EULA with Bosch including non-standard terms and conditions, as Bosch sets the industry standard to obtain vehicle forensics for vehicles involved in collisions and Crash Data Group, Inc. is the sole distributor. It is in the County’s best interest to have access to this software to facilitate the Department’s thorough investigation of cases involving vehicle collisions, including but not limited to vehicular homicide, major injury collision, arson, and auto insurance fraud investigations, and to continue assisting other County departments and law enforcement agencies with retrieving vehicle forensic information.
PROCUREMENT
County Policy 11-05 requires Board approval of the non-standard contract provisions discussed above. The Department has been using the CDR Toolkit since May 2018 and plans to continue utilizing it for the next several years. This is a non-competitive procurement as Bosch is the developer of the hardware and software and Crash Data Group, Inc. is the sole distributor of the CDR Toolkit. Pursuant to County Policy 11-04, the Purchasing Agent has the authority to approve the purchase of goods and services which do not exceed a $200,000 annual cost. Recommendation No. 2, however, is included in this item as the purchase is tied to the approval of nonstandard software terms.
The Purchasing Department concurs with the non-competitive justification of sole source for the software subscription, hardware upgrades, and training to use the CDR Toolkit. If Bosch revises its terms and conditions of its EULA during the subscription period, County Counsel will review the changes to determine if the Department needs to obtain additional approval from the Board.
REVIEW BY OTHERS
This item has been reviewed by County Counsel (Katherine Hardy, Deputy County Counsel, 387-5455) on June 25, 2023; Risk Management (Victor Tordesillas, Director, 386-8621) on June 27, 2023; Purchasing (Michelle Churchill, Supervising Buyer, 387-2070) on July 5, 2023; Finance (Kathleen Gonzalez, Administrative Analyst, 387-5412) on July 11, 2023; and County Finance and Administration (Robert Saldana, Deputy Executive Officer, 387-5423) on July 11, 2023.