Legislation Details

File #: 9009   
Type: Discussion Status: Agenda Ready
File created: 10/20/2023 Department: Project and Facilities Management
On agenda: 10/24/2023 Final action:
Subject: Capital Improvement Program Project, Construction Contract and Service Agreement with Alliance Building Solutions, Inc. for the Energy Efficiency Solutions Project in San Bernardino
Attachments: 1. ADD-EXH-PFMD-102423-Exhibit E - ABS Project Representation and Key Personnel, 2. ADD-EXH-PFMD-102423-Exhibit F - Submittal Schedule, 3. ADD-EXH-PFMD-102423-Exhibit G - Senate Bill 1439 – Contractor Information Report, 4. ADD-EXH-PFMD-102423-Exhibit H - Geotechnical Reference Documents, 5. ADD-EXH-PFMD-102423-Exhibit I - General Conditions, 6. ADD-EXH-PFMD-102423-Exhibit J - Special Conditions, 7. ADD-RES-PFMD-102423-Energy Efficiency Solution Agreement with Alliance Resolution, 8. ADD-ATT-PFMD-102423-Contract Award-Alliance Bldg Solutions Inc-NOE, 9. ADD-CON-PFMD-102423-Contract Award-Alliance Bldg Solutions Inc._10.24.pdf, 10. PPT-PFMD-102423-Energy Efficiency Solutions Agreement.pdf, 11. ADD-CON-PFMD-102423-Service Contract-Alliance Bldg Solutions, Inc., 12. ADD-EXH-PFMD-102423-Exhibit B1 - ABS Scope of Work, including Attachments A - F, 13. ADD-EXH-PFMD-102423-Exhibit B2 - ABS Scope of Work, including Attachments A - F, 14. ADD-COV-PFMD-102423-Contract Award-Alliance Bldg Solutions Inc, 15. ADD-COV-PFMD-102423-Service Contract Award -Alliance Bldg Solutions, Inc, 16. Item #90 Executed BAI, 17. 2023-188 Executed Resolution, 18. 23-1178 Executed Contract, 19. 23-1177 Executed Contract

REPORT/RECOMMENDATION TO THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS

OF SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY

AND RECORD OF ACTION

 

October 24, 2023

 

FROM

DON DAY, Director, Project and Facilities Management Department

         

SUBJECT                      

Title                     

Capital Improvement Program Project, Construction Contract and Service Agreement with Alliance Building Solutions, Inc. for the Energy Efficiency Solutions Project in San Bernardino

End

 

RECOMMENDATIONS

Recommendation

1.                     Conduct a public hearing on the Energy Efficiency Solutions Project.

2.                     Find that the Energy Efficiency Solutions Project is exempt under California Environmental Quality Act Guidelines, Section 15301 Class 1, Subsection (e)(1) minor alteration of existing structure.

3.                     Approve Capital Improvement Program Project No. 24-100, in the amount of $9,092,408, for the Energy Efficiency Solutions Project.

4.                     Authorize the Auditor-Controller/Treasurer/Tax Collector to post necessary budget adjustments for the Capital Improvement Program Project to the 2023-24 budget as detailed in the Financial Impact section (Four votes required).

5.                     Approve plans and specifications for the Energy Efficiency Solutions Project, located at 385 North Arrowhead Avenue and 268 West Hospitality Lane in San Bernardino.

6.                     Find that it is in the best interest of the County to enter into an Energy Efficiency Solutions Agreement with Alliance Building Solutions, Inc., and that the anticipated cost to the County from the services provided by Alliance Building Solutions, Inc. will be less than the anticipated cost to the County of the energy that would have been consumed by the County.

7.                     Adopt Resolution authorizing the Board of Supervisors to enter into an Energy Efficiency Solutions Agreement with Alliance Building Solutions, Inc., for the installation of energy-related improvements at 385 North Arrowhead Avenue and 268 West Hospitality Lane in San Bernardino.

8.                     Award Energy Efficiency Solutions Agreement to Alliance Building Solutions, Inc., in the amount of $7,880,230, which includes an allowance amount of $80,000 to be used in the event unforeseen supplemental structural roof framing members are required, for a contract period of 545 calendar days from the date of the issuance of the Notice to Proceed for the Energy Efficiency Solutions Project.

9.                     Authorize the Director of the Project and Facilities Management Department to order any necessary changes or additions in the work being performed under the Energy Efficiency Solutions Agreement, for a total amount not to exceed $210,000 pursuant to Public Contract Code Section 20142.

10.                     Approve Service Agreement with Alliance Building Solutions, Inc., including non-standard terms, for measurement and verification services and savings guarantee of the energy production associated with the Scope of Work described in the Energy Efficiency Solutions Agreement, for the not-to-exceed amount of $458,085, for the period of October 24, 2023 through October 24, 2043.

11.                     Authorize the Director of the Project and Facilities Management Department to accept the work when 100% complete and execute and file the Notice of Completion.

12.                     Direct the Clerk of the Board of Supervisors to file and post the Notice of Exemption of the Energy Efficiency Solutions Project as required by the California Environmental Quality Act. 

(Presenter: Don Day, Director, 387-5000)

Body

 

COUNTY AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER GOALS & OBJECTIVES

Promote the Countywide Vision.

Ensure Development of a Well-Planned, Balanced, and Sustainable County.

 

FINANCIAL IMPACT

Approval of this item will result in the use of additional Discretionary General Funding (Net County Cost) in the amount of $9,092,408 for the Energy Efficiency Solutions Project (Project) (WBSE 10.10.1566), which consists of the Energy Efficiency Solutions Agreement in the amount of $7,880,230 and the Capital Improvement Program costs of $1,212,178. In addition, Discretionary General Funding will fund approximately $22,905 annually through the Utilities Budget (7770001000) towards the measurement and verification services of energy production for 20 years. Approval of the necessary appropriation and revenue adjustments are not requested at this time for measurement and verification services but will be included in a future budget report presented to the Board of Supervisors (Board) for approval, if necessary. Sufficient appropriation and revenue will be included in future recommended budgets.

 

The Department requests the Auditor-Controller/Treasurer/Tax Collector post the following adjustments to the 2023-24 budget:

 

Fund Center

Commitment Item

Description

Action

Amount

WBSE

1161161000

55305030

Operating Transfer Out

Increase

$9,092,408

-

1280001000

56006000

Contingencies

Decrease

$9,092,408

-

7700003100

54304030

Structures & Improvement to Structures

Increase

$9,092,408

10.10.1566

7700003100

40909975

Operating Transfer In

Increase

$9,092,408

10.10.1566

 

BACKGROUND INFORMATION

Following California State-wide sustainability efforts, San Bernardino County (County) is committed to reducing its environmental footprint through sustainable County government operations and practices as part of its goals and objectives. Amidst the volatility in the utility market, the Project and Facilities Management Department (PFMD) is seeking opportunities to incorporate environmentally preferable products, energy-efficient County building design, and construction, and substantially reduce the costs and environmental impacts associated with operating County-owned and leased facilities.

 

In 2022, Alliance Building Solutions, Inc. (ABS) contacted the County to evaluate sustainable opportunities within County-owned facilities. ABS conducted a Payback Overview that included a Cost and Savings Analysis and Cumulative Savings report, which supported a proposal to install energy-efficient measures, lighting, heating ventilation and air-conditioning (HVAC), system controls, and solar photovoltaic (PV) energy. The proposal covered the County-owned facilities at 385 North Arrowhead Avenue and 268 West Hospitality Lane in San Bernardino; the improvements to each facility vary and were chosen to maximize the energy savings potential at each individual facility. The County can consider procuring services from ABS using California Government Code 4217.10 through 4217.18.

 

In accordance with the Government Code 4217.12, a Notice of Hearing was released on October 10 2023, giving notice that the Board would be conducting a hearing, during its regular meeting, to award an Energy Efficiency Solutions Agreement to ABS on October 24, 2023. Additionally, in accordance with California Government Code 4217.10 to 4217.18, the Board must find it is in the best interest of the County to enter into an energy services agreement for the installation of energy-related improvements whose cost to the County under the agreement will be less than the anticipated cost to the County of thermal, electrical or other energy that would have been consumed by the County in the absence of the improvements and adopt a Resolution with these findings. ABS warrants that the anticipated cost to the County for the services provided by ABS ($7,880,230) are less than the anticipated costs to the County for energy that would have been used by the County, which is projected to cost $18,670,797 over 30 years. After completion of the work by ABS, PFMD will verify the new equipment is installed, tested, and operating as designed to optimize energy efficiency.

 

The recommended item will establish a Capital Improvement Program for the Project and award an Energy Efficiency Solutions Agreement to ABS for the Project located at 385 North Arrowhead Avenue and 268 West Hospitality Lane in San Bernardino. The Project will consist of Light Emitting Diode conversion of lighting, replacement of existing electrical transformers, and replacement of existing HVAC systems and various equipment. 268 West Hospitality Lane’s scope will also include a high efficiency heating hot water boiler and a solar PV carport system with a battery energy storage system.

 

The Energy Efficiency Solutions Agreement with ABS in the amount of $7,880,230 includes an allowance of $80,000 to be used in the event unforeseen supplemental structural roof framing members are required.  Inclusion of the allowance for unknown scope will facilitate Project completion in a timely manner.  If the cost of unknown site conditions is higher or lower than the allowance amount, the Agreement amount will be revised through use of a change order.

 

The Service Agreement with ABS for the measurement and verification services and savings guarantee shall commence upon the completion and acceptance by the County and final payment by the County to ABS of the solar PV carport system installation at 268 W. Hospitality Lane in San Bernardino, per the Energy Efficiency Solutions Agreement. The annual Service Agreement charge is $0 for the first year, $15,000 for the second year, and escalated at 5% annually for every subsequent year thereafter up to 20 years. The maximum payment under this Service Agreement shall not exceed $458,085.

 

The Service Agreement with ABS includes terms that differ from the standard County contract.  The non-standard terms include the following:

 

1.                     The term of the Service Agreement is 20 years, although the County may terminate the Service Agreement with 30 days’ notice to ABS.

•                     County policies 11-05 and 11-06 SP1 state that the standard County contract term is five years, unless approved by the Board.

•                     Potential Impact:  The County is bound by the terms of the Service Agreement for 20 years unless the County terminates the Service Agreement.

 

2.                     The Service Agreement includes a limitation of liability that states ABS will not work on any equipment or comply with recommendations of insurance companies, ABS will only make repairs within 90 days of determining equipment is in need of repair or the equipment will be removed from the Service Agreement, and if in ABS’s opinion equipment cannot be properly repaired ABS may withdraw the equipment and adjust the energy savings.

•                     The County standard contract does not include a limitation of liability.

•                     Potential Impact: The County’s ability to require ABS repair equipment is limited, which may impact the County’s energy savings.

 

PFMD recommends approval of the Service Agreement with ABS, including the non-standard terms, to confirm the energy savings provided by the solar PV carport system through a measurement and verification process and strengthen the County’s ability to recover deficits in savings projections.

 

It is recommended that the Board determine the Project to be categorically exempt from further review under Section 15301, Additions to Existing Structures, of the California Environmental Quality Act Guidelines (Title 14, California Code of Regulations). As evidenced by the Notice of Exemption, Section 15301, Class 1 Existing Facilities, Subsection (e)(1) minor alterations with no or negligible expansion of former use, which provides categorical exemption for projects.

 

PROCUREMENT

Energy service agreements are authorized by California Government Code sections 4217.10 through 4217.18, which provide that a public agency may enter into an energy services contract on such terms as the Board determines are in the best interest of the County if "the anticipated cost to the public agency for thermal or electrical energy or conservation services provided by the energy conservation facility under contract will be less than the anticipated marginal cost to the public agency of thermal, electrical, or other energy that would have been consumed in the absence of these purchases." This simply means that the energy savings will be equal to or greater than the project costs.

 

This is a noncompetitive procurement as permitted by Government Code 4217.10 through 4217.18. On October 10, 2023, San Bernardino County released a Notice of Public Hearing.

 

REVIEW BY OTHERS

This item has been reviewed by County Counsel (Julie Surber, Principal Assistant County Counsel, 387-5455) on September 28, 2023; Auditor-Controller/Treasurer/Tax Collector (Charlene Huang, Auditor-Controller Manager, 382-7022) on October 17, 2023; Purchasing (Ariel Gill, Lead Buyer, 777-0722) on September 28, 2023; Project and Facilities Management (Robert Gilliam, Chief of Project Management, 387-3072) on September 29, 2023; Finance (Yael Verduzco, Principal Administrative Analyst, 387-5285) on October 18, 2023; and County Finance and Administration (Valerie Clay, Deputy Executive Officer, 387-5423) October 18, 2023.

 

(DD: 601-4936)