Legislation Details

File #: 9008   
Type: Discussion Status: Passed
File created: 10/20/2023 Department: San Bernardino County Fire Protection District
On agenda: 10/24/2023 Final action: 10/24/2023
Subject: Initiative Petition to Repeal the Special Tax for San Bernardino County Fire Protection District Service Zone FP-5
Attachments: 1. RES-SBCFPD-10242023- FP-5 Repeal Measure - Special All-Mail Ballot Election on 1-30-24 Final, 2. RES-SBCFPD-10242023- FP-5 Repeal Measure - Special Election on 1-23-24 Final, 3. RES-SBCFPD-10242023- FP-5 Repeal Measure - Special Election on 1-30-24 Final, 4. RES-SBCFPD-10242023- FP-5 Repeal Measure - Special All-Mail Ballot Election on 1-23-24 Final, 5. ORD-SBCFPD-10-24-23-FP-5 Repeal Measure Final, 6. PPT-SBCFPD-102423-FP-5 Repeal Measure.pdf, 7. Item #92 Executed BAI, 8. 2023-191 Executed Resolution, 9. RES-SBCFPD-10242023- FP-5 Repeal Measure - Consolidated Election on 3-5-24 Final

REPORT/RECOMMENDATION TO THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS

OF SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY FIRE PROTECTION DISTRICT

AND RECORD OF ACTION

 

October 24, 2023

 

FROM

DAN MUNSEY, Fire Chief/Fire Warden, San Bernardino County Fire Protection District

STEPHENIE SHEA, Registrar of Voters 

         

SUBJECT                      

Title                     

Initiative Petition to Repeal the Special Tax for San Bernardino County Fire Protection District Service Zone FP-5

End

 

RECOMMENDATION(S)

Recommendation

AMENDED-

Acting as the governing body of the San Bernardino County Fire Protection District:

1.                     Find that the proposed actions are exempt from review pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act and in accordance with California Environmental Quality Act Guidelines Section 15061(b)(3) (General Rule).

2.                     Accept the Certificate of Initiative Petition dated October 10, 2023, with respect to the initiative petition entitled “Initiative to Repeal the Special Tax for San Bernardino County Fire Protection District Service Zone FP-5” that was filed with the Registrar of Voters on August 29, 2023.

3.                     Pursuant to California Elections Code section 9310(a), the Board of Directors shall do only one of the following:

a.                     Consider a proposed ordinance relating to the adoption of the “Initiative to Repeal the Special Tax for San Bernardino County Fire Protection District Service Zone FP-5” without alteration; approve introduction of proposed ordinance; and SCHEDULE ORDINANCE FOR FINAL ADOPTION ON TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 14, 2023, on the Consent Calendar.

•                     An ordinance of the San Bernardino County Fire Protection District to adopt the Initiative Petition that repeals the special tax for San Bernardino County Fire Protection District Service Zone FP-5; or

b.                     Submit the “Initiative to Repeal the Special Tax for San Bernardino County Fire Protection District Service Zone FP-5”, without alteration, to the voters pursuant to Elections Code section 1405.

4.                     If the Board of Directors approves Recommendation 3.b., above, pursuant to Elections Code section 1405, the Board of Directors shall do only one of the following:

a.                     Adopt Resolution calling an election for the “Initiative to Repeal the Special Tax for San Bernardino County Fire Protection District Service Zone FP-5” to be consolidated with the March 5, 2024, Presidential Primary Election (San Bernardino County Fire Protection District’s next regular election); or

b.                     Adopt Resolution calling a special election for the “Initiative to Repeal the Special Tax for San Bernardino County Fire Protection District Service Zone FP-5” on January 23, 2024 (not less than 88 days nor more than 103 days from today’s date); or

c.                     Adopt Resolution calling a special election for the “Initiative to Repeal the Special Tax for San Bernardino County Fire Protection District Service Zone FP-5” on January 30, 2024 (not less than 88 days nor more than 103 days from today’s date); or

d.                     Adopt Resolution calling a special all-mail ballot election for the “Initiative to Repeal the Special Tax for San Bernardino County Fire Protection District Service Zone FP-5” on January 23, 2024 (pursuant to Elections Code section 4108); or

e.                     Adopt Resolution calling a special all-mail ballot election for the “Initiative to Repeal the Special Tax for San Bernardino County Fire Protection District Service Zone FP-5” on January 30, 2024 (pursuant to Elections Code section 4108).

5.                     If the Board of Directors approves Recommendation 3.b., above, the Board of Directors directs the Registrar of Voters to do one of the following:

a.                     Not print the full initiative in the ballot materials unless the petitioner requests to have the full initiative printed and agrees to pay for the additional costs; or                     

b.                     Print the full initiative in the ballot materials.

 

(Presenter: Dan Munsey, Fire Chief/Fire Warden, 387-5779)

Body

 

COUNTY AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER GOALS & OBJECTIVES

Operate in a Fiscally-Responsible and Business-Like Manner.

Pursue County Goals and Objectives by Working with Other Agencies and Stakeholders.

 

FINANCIAL IMPACT

Approval of this item will not result in the use of additional Discretionary General Funding (Net County Cost).

 

Pursuant to County Code section 16.0224(d) of the County Fee Ordinance, the Registrar of Voters (ROV) will bill San Bernardino County Fire Protection District (SBCFPD) for all costs plus overhead related to the examination of signatures and certification of this initiative petition, which is estimated to cost approximately $7,106.

 

Should the Board of Directors (Board) choose to adopt by ordinance the “Initiative to Repeal the Special Tax for San Bernardino County Fire Protection District Service Zone FP-5” (Initiative Petition/Measure) repealing the special tax associated with Fire Protection District Service Zone Five (FP-5) (Recommendation No. 3a.), or should an election occur (Recommendation No. 3.b.) and the Initiative Petition/Measure is adopted/passes, this would result in properties within FP-5 no longer being subject to the annual FP-5 special tax (currently $171.85 per parcel). SBCFPD would experience a reduction in revenue of approximately $46,500,000 annually, representing approximately 19% of the SBCFPD 2023-24 operating budget, resulting in less fire protection and emergency medical services to the public.

 

If the Board decides to submit the Initiative Petition/Measure, without alteration, to the voters pursuant to Elections Code section 1405 (Recommendation No. 3.b.), the cost of the election (estimated at $2,800,000 for a special polling place election; $1,500,000 for a special all-mail ballot election; and $1,300,000 if consolidated with the March 5, 2024, Presidential Primary Election) would be funded by SBCFPD through the use of available reserves.

 

Recommendation No. 5 requests that the Board provide direction to ROV whether to include the full text of the initiative in ballot materials.  If the full text is not printed, it is estimated that it will decrease the costs of the election by $216,570.

 

BACKGROUND INFORMATION

ROV has determined that the proponents of Initiative Petition/Measure entitled “Initiative to Repeal the Special Tax for San Bernardino County Fire Protection District Service Zone FP-5” collected more than a sufficient number of valid registered voter signatures within the prescribed time period to qualify the Initiative Petition/Measure for adoption or for placement on an election ballot for consideration of the voters of SBCFPD.

 

The proponents of the Initiative Petition/Measure are Robert A. Cable, Albert H. Vogler, Ruth Musser-Lopez, and David Jarvi. ROV is the elections official for SBCFPD.

 

On May 9, 2023, pursuant to the District Elections law codified in Elections Code section 9300 et seq., proponents submitted to ROV a proof of publication of a Notice of Intention to circulate the Initiative Petition/Measure that would repeal the special tax associated with FP-5.

 

On August 29, 2023, the proponents submitted the Initiative Petition/Measure to ROV containing 11,255 signatures, which was within the 180 days provided to collect signatures from registered voters residing within SBCFPD. For ROV to declare the Initiative Petition/Measure sufficient, 6,727 valid signatures were required pursuant to Proposition 218, Article XIII C, section 3, of the California Constitution. In the November 8, 2022, Statewide General Election, 134,538 SBCFPD voters voted for one of the two candidates for Governor. Pursuant to the requirement of Proposition 218, signatures from 5% of voters are required in order to meet the signature requirement.

 

Pursuant to the authority provided in Elections Code section 9309, ROV examined a random sample of 500 signatures on the Initiative Petition/Measure. Further, pursuant to section 9309(a), ROV was required to complete its random sample examination of Initiative Petition/Measure signatures within 30 business days from the date of filing, which set the deadline of October 12, 2023. ROV followed the administrative requirements of the California Code of Regulations sections 20510 through 20540 Election Petition Signature Verification Random Sampling Verification Methodology to project that the Initiative Petition/Measure contained 8,441 verified valid signatures, which is more than 110 percent of the required number. As a result, examination of all signatures was not required by state law.

 

The Registrar of Voters executed the Certificate of Initiative Petition on October 10, 2023, and notified the proponents of the sufficiency of the Initiative Petition/Measure. This was within the 30 business-day random sampling examination deadline of October 12, 2023. Pursuant to Elections Code section 9309(f), the Registrar of Voters is required to present the Certificate of Initiative Petition to the Board at its next regular meeting.

 

As a result of receiving the certification from the ROV, pursuant to Elections Code section 9310, the Board shall either adopt the ordinance, without alteration (either as part of this item or within 10 days of this item); or submit the Initiative Petition/Measure, without alteration, to the voters pursuant to Elections Code section 1405.

 

If the Board decides to submit the Initiative Petition/Measure to the voters (Recommendation No. 3.b.), Elections Code section 1405(a) states, in part, that "the election for a municipal or district initiative that qualifies pursuant to Section 9215 or 9310 shall be held at the jurisdiction's next regular election occurring not less than 88 days after the date of the order of election". The next regular election will occur on March 5, 2024.

 

Elections Code section 1405(b) also allows the Board to call a special election for the purpose of submitting the Initiative Petition/Measure to the voters before the date on which the Initiative Petition/Measure would appear on the ballot pursuant to Elections Code section 1405(a). Such special election is required to be held not less than 88 days nor more than 103 days after the order of the election. This time period would range from January 20, 2024, to February 4, 2024, however, an election can only be held on a Tuesday, narrowing the possible dates to January 23, 2024, or January 30, 2024. Pursuant to Elections Code section 4108, the Board may direct, by Resolution, that a special all-mail ballot election be held on a date other than an established election date.  A special all-mail ballot election could be held on either January 23, 2024, or January 30, 2024.

 

County Counsel drafted the recommended ballot question language for the Initiative Petition/Measure contained in the five potential Resolutions presented for Board consideration (Recommendation Nos. 4.a., 4.b., 4.c., 4.d. and 4.e.). If the Board adopts one of the Resolutions, Counsel will also draft an impartial analysis of the Initiative Petition/Measure.  County Counsel has also drafted an ordinance for Board consideration if the Board chooses Recommendation No. 3.a. 

 

Should an election occur, passage of the Initiative Petition/Measure would require approval from a simple majority (50% plus one) of the voters residing within SBCFPD that cast a vote on the Initiative Petition/Measure.

 

PROCUREMENT

Not applicable.

 

REVIEW BY OTHERS

This item has been reviewed by County Counsel (Jolena Grider, Deputy County Counsel, and Scott Runyan, Principal Assistant County Counsel, 387-5455) on October 13, 2023; Registrar of Voters (Stephenie Shea, Registrar of Voters, 387-2100) on October 17, 2023; San Bernardino County Fire Protection District (Dan Munsey, Fire Chief/Fire Warden, 387-5779) on October 13, 2023; Finance (Elias Duenas, Administrative Analyst, and Tom Forster, Administrative Analyst, 387-5423) on October 17, 2023; and County Finance and Administration (Valerie Clay, Deputy Executive Officer, 387-5423) on October 17, 2023.