REPORT/RECOMMENDATION TO THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
OF SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY
AND RECORD OF ACTION
February 28, 2023
FROM
LEONARD X. HERNANDEZ, Chief Executive Officer, County Administration Office
SUBJECT
Title
Appointment of County Representative to the Technical Review Panel for the Cadiz Valley Groundwater Conservation, Recovery, and Storage Project’s Groundwater Management, Monitoring and Mitigation Plan
End
RECOMMENDATION(S)
Recommendation
1. Approve the appointment of William Halligan, as the County representative, to the Technical Review Panel for the Cadiz Valley Groundwater Conservation, Recovery, and Storage Project’s Groundwater Management, Monitoring and Mitigation Plan, for an initial five-year term, effective retroactively from January 30, 2023, and expiring January 29, 2028, subject to the terms of a standard professional services agreement.
2. Delegate authority to the Chief Executive Officer to approve the future appointment or re-appointment of the County representative to the Technical Review Panel during the Cadiz Valley Groundwater Conservation, Recovery, and Storage Project’s estimated 60 year plus operational and closure period, approve the appointment of the third Technical Review Panel representative selected by the County and Santa Margarita Water District’s Technical Review Panel representatives, and approve the Technical Review Panel Operating Procedures for the Cadiz Valley Groundwater Conservation, Recovery, and Storage Project’s Management Plan.
(Presenter: Luther Snoke, Chief Operating Officer, 387-3101)
Body
COUNTY AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER GOALS & OBJECTIVES
Ensure Development of a Well-Planned, Balanced, and Sustainable County.
Provide for the Safety, Health and Social Service Needs of County Residents.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
Approval of this item may result in the use of additional Discretionary General Funding (Net County Cost). Section 8.1.2 of the Groundwater Management, Monitoring and Mitigation Plan (Management Plan) for the Cadiz Valley Groundwater Conservation, Recovery, and Storage Project (Water Project) requires that the Technical Review Panel’s (TRP) costs be borne by Fenner Valley Mutual Water Company (FVMWC), including those of the technical representatives, provided that annual costs do not exceed $60,000 per year for all three TRP representatives, escalated by 2% per year as of 2012. Because the annual costs are split between a three-member TRP, the County anticipates recovering one-third of the annual payments from FVMWC to cover the costs incurred by the County’s TRP representative.
Anticipating that the annual costs of the County’s TRP representative may exceed the annual contribution provided by FVMWC during any given year of the Water Project’s operational period, the County will be contracting with the County’s TRP representative pursuant to the terms of a standard professional services agreement approved by the County’s Purchasing Agent that will compensate the County TRP representative in an amount not to exceed $100,000 annually, which includes the $20,000 borne by FVMWC. The cost of the County’s TRP representative is not expected to exceed the annual reimbursement threshold borne by FVMWC during the County’s 2022-23 fiscal year. Therefore, the use of Discretionary General Funding is not requested at this time. However, budget adjustments will be presented to the Board of Supervisors (Board) for approval to cover the future costs of the County’s TRP representative, if necessary.
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
On October 1, 2012 (Item No. 1), the Board, acting as a Responsible Agency under the California Environmental Quality Act, approved the Management Plan for the Water Project. As described in the executive summary of the Management Plan, the Water Project is a 50-year groundwater recovery, conservation and conjunctive use storage project located within the collective Fenner, Orange Blossom Wash, Bristol and Cadiz Watersheds in the Eastern Mojave Desert. It will provide reliable water supply to the Santa Margarita Water District (SMWD) and other participating water agencies.
The Management Plan governs the operation and management of the Water Project by FVMWC through a joint powers agreement initially between FVMWC and SMWD. The Management Plan was prepared to comply with the County’s Desert Groundwater Management Ordinance as an excluded project under the exclusion provisions set forth in Section 33.06552 of the County Code. The Management Plan requires monitoring of aquifer health and safe yield, groundwater levels and rates of decline, groundwater quality, subsidence, surface vegetation, air quality, third-party wells and springs, and corrective measures to address potential significant adverse impacts to critical resources and undesirable results attributable to the Water Project.
As set forth in Chapter 8 of the Management Plan, the creation of a TRP is required in order to assist in evaluating monitoring protocols and methods of data collection and processing, water quality, the rate of decline in groundwater elevation, monitoring the level of the water table in relation to an established safe floor, and the Water Project’s potential to cause undesirable results. The TRP may make recommendations to the County or the County may request recommendations from the TRP that require additional monitoring, mitigation, and modification to the Water Project’s operations.
The TRP consist of three members, one technical representative appointed by SMWD, one technical representative appointed by the County, and one technical representative jointly selected by the technical representatives from SMWD and the County, subject to review and approval by SMWD and the County. The TRP is required to convene at least once every year to discuss and act with respect to its responsibilities. The members will elect a chair and rotate the position annually. Any determinations or recommendation shall require the affirmative vote of at least two members, if there is not a consensus the dissenting views will be included in the submittals. All three members of the TRP are required to possess professional technical qualifications appropriate to the tasks of the TRP and must have a minimum of 10 years professional experience working in the groundwater field.
This item recommends the selection of William Halligan (Consultant) as the County’s technical representative to the TRP. The Consultant is an experienced hydrogeologist that consulted with the County as part of the review and approval of the Management Plan.
This item also includes a request for delegated authority to the County’s Chief Executive Officer (CEO) to approve future appointments or re-appointments of the County TRP representative for the Water Project’s Management Plan. Because the responsibilities of the TRP require oversight of the Water Project, which has an operational period that will span 50 years and a post-operational/closure period that will span a minimum of 10 year (Management Plan Term), this item will delegate authority to the CEO to appoint or re-appoint the County TRP representative at the expiration of the Consultant’s term. Any future appointment or re-appointment of the County TRP representative during the Management Plan Term shall be subject to the terms and qualifications previously set forth by the Water Project’s Management Plan. This item also includes the delegated authority for the CEO to approve the future appointment of the third TRP representative selected by the County and SMWD’s TRP representatives, as well as authority for the CEO to approve the TRP Operating Procedures that are required by the Water Project’s Management Plan. A retroactive appointment is requested for this item due to the need for Consultant’s services and expertise on reviewing and considering the proposed selection of the third TRP member by SMWD, and therefore to ensure the Consultant’s term on the TRP runs parallel and in conjunction with the contract term for the standard professional services agreement approved by the County’s Purchasing Agent.
PROCUREMENT
Standard policies and rules for the selection of County boards, commissions and committees, regulated by County Policy No. 02-09, do not govern the procurement and selection of County TRP members. The Consultant was selected and appointed in accordance with the Water Project’s Management Plan.
REVIEW BY OTHERS
This item has been reviewed by County Counsel (Jason M. Searles, Supervising Deputy County Counsel, 387-5455) on January 30, 2023; Finance (Erika Rodarte, Administrative Analyst, 387-4919) on February 2, 2023; and County Finance and Administration (Robert J. Saldana, Deputy Executive Officer, 387-4342) on February 3, 2023.