Legislation Details

File #: 8947   
Type: Consent Status: Passed
File created: 10/13/2023 Department: Multijurisdictional Items
On agenda: 10/24/2023 Final action: 10/24/2023
Subject: Non-Financial Agreements with Space Exploration Technologies Corp. for Starlink Satellite-Based Internet Service and Software Licenses
Attachments: 1. COV-MULTI-ITD-10-24-23-Software License and Usage Terms Agreement, 2. COV-MULTI-ITD-10-24-23-Starlink Acceptable Use Policy, 3. COV-MULTI-ITD-10-24-23-Starlink Terms of Service Agreement, 4. CON-MULTI-ITD-10-24-23-Software License and Usage Terms Agreement, 5. CON-MULTI-ITD-10-24-23-Starlink Acceptable Use Policy, 6. CON-MULTI-ITD-10-24-23-Starlink Terms of Service Agreement, 7. Item #83 Executed BAI

REPORT/RECOMMENDATION TO THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS

OF SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY

BOARD GOVERNED COUNTY SERVICE AREAS

SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY FLOOD CONTROL DISTRICT

AND RECORD OF ACTION

 

REPORT/RECOMMENDATION TO THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS

OF THE SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY FIRE PROTECTION DISTRICT

INLAND COUNTIES EMERGENCY MEDICAL AGENCY

IN-HOME SUPPORTIVE SERVICES PUBLIC AUTHORITY

BLOOMINGTON RECREATION AND PARK DISTRICT

BIG BEAR VALLEY RECREATION AND PARK DISTRICT

AND RECORD OF ACTION

 

October 24, 2023

 

FROM

LYNN FYHRLUND, Chief Information Officer, Innovation and Technology Department 

         

SUBJECT                      

Title                     

Non-Financial Agreements with Space Exploration Technologies Corp. for Starlink Satellite-Based Internet Service and Software Licenses

End

 

RECOMMENDATION(S)

Recommendation

1.                     Acting as the governing body for San Bernardino County, and as the governing body for the Board Governed County Service Areas; San Bernardino County Flood Control District; Big Bear Valley Recreation and Park District; Bloomington Recreation and Park District; In-Home Supportive Services Public Authority; Inland Counties Emergency Medical Agency; and San Bernardino County Fire Protection District, approve the following non-financial template agreements with Space Exploration Technologies Corp., including non-standard terms, for Starlink satellite-based internet service and software licenses, which shall remain in effect for as long as the County and its affiliated agencies continue to access or use the underlying software, or until terminated in accordance with the provisions of the agreements:

a.                     Starlink Terms of Service

b.                     Acceptable Use Policy

c.                     Software License and Usage Terms

2.                     Acting as the governing body for San Bernardino County, designate the Chief Information Officer, Assistant Chief Information Officer, or Innovation and Technology Division Chief as the representatives authorized for San Bernardino County to electronically accept the template agreements identified in Recommendation No. 1 and future updates to the template agreements, subject to review by County Counsel, provided that such updated terms do not substantively modify the terms of the original template agreements.

3.                     Acting as the governing body for the Board Governed County Service Areas; San Bernardino County Flood Control District; Big Bear Valley Recreation and Park District; Bloomington Recreation and Park District; In-Home Supportive Services Public Authority; Inland Counties Emergency Medical Agency; and San Bernardino County Fire Protection District, designate the Chief Executive Officer as the representative authorized for Board Governed County Service Areas; San Bernardino County Flood Control District; Big Bear Valley Recreation and Park District; Bloomington Recreation and Park District; In-Home Supportive Services Public Authority; Inland Counties Emergency Medical Agency; and San Bernardino County Fire Protection District, to electronically accept the template agreements identified in Recommendation No. 1 and future updates to the template agreements, subject to review by County Counsel, provided that such updated terms do not substantively modify the terms of the original template agreements.

(Presenter: Lynn Fyhrlund, Chief Information Officer, 388-5501)

Body

 

COUNTY AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER GOALS & OBJECTIVES

Improve County Government Operations.

Provide for the Safety, Health, and Social Service Needs of County Residents.

 

FINANCIAL IMPACT

Approval of this item will not result in the use of Discretionary General Funding (Net County Cost). The template agreements are non-financial in nature and do not commit the Innovation and Technology Department (ITD), the County, and its affiliated agencies to make any purchases. If future purchases are made in conjunction with these template agreements, ITD, the County, and its affiliated agencies will adhere to their purchasing policies and return to the Board of Supervisors/Board of Directors (Board) for approval, if necessary.

 

BACKGROUND INFORMATION

Multiple County departments and affiliated agencies require satellite-based internet service to provide viable and robust internet access in remote areas where cable or fiber optic network infrastructure is non-existent or in situations where mobility is required. Starlink is a satellite-based internet service provided by Space Exploration Technologies Corp. (SpaceX). This service is based on SpaceX’s placement of thousands of small satellites in low Earth orbit that work in combination with ground transceivers.

 

According to information published by SpaceX, Starlink satellites are over 60 times closer to Earth than traditional satellites. This results in lower latency, which is the time it takes to send data from one point to the next, enabling support for services that require low latency to function, such as voice and video-based services. These services are not normally available through traditional satellite internet service providers because of the high latency associated with more distant satellites.

 

On March 9, 2021 (Item No. 16), the Board approved Agreement No. 21-191 with SpaceX for the provision of Beta Starlink, a service order and statement of work in the amount of $61,464, plus applicable taxes for the period of March 15, 2021, through March 14, 2022. The service order and statement of work allowed the County to purchase the required equipment to test Starlink to explore new technologies for the purpose of increasing services provided to County residents and communities served. The Beta Starlink testing was successful and met the needs of County departments. Continued use of this service requires acceptance of the template agreements listed in Recommendation No. 1.

 

The Starlink Terms of Service Agreement, Acceptable Use Policy Agreement, and Software License and Usage Terms Agreement (collectively Agreements) are Starlink’s standard commercial agreements, which include terms that differ or are omitted from the standard County contract. These non-negotiable clickwrap Agreements are accepted by a click on the link provided at the time of the order. The non-standard and missing terms include the following:

 

1.                     All disputes arising under the Agreements must be settled by binding arbitration.

•                     The County standard contract does not require arbitration.

•                     Potential Impact:  Arbitration decisions are not appealable. In addition, disputes that might otherwise be settled in small claims court would incur arbitration costs that would exceed the costs of a small claims action, and the amount of the Agreements.

 

2.                     Starlink may change the Agreements’ terms at any time and will provide notice of material changes. The County’s continued use of the services constitutes acceptance of the modified terms.

•                     The County standard contract requires that any changes to the contract be reduced to writing, executed, and attached to the original contract and approved by the person(s) authorized to do so on behalf of the contractor and the County.

•                     Potential Impact:  The County could be agreeing to new terms without review by anyone, including County Counsel, and without approval of the new terms by the Board.

 

3.                     Starlink may assign the Agreements without notice to the County and without the County’s approval.

•                     The County standard contract requires that the County must approve any assignment of the contract.

•                     Potential Impact:  Starlink could assign the Agreements to a third party or business with which the County is legally prohibited from doing business due to issues of Federal debarment or suspension and conflict of interest, without the County’s knowledge. Should this occur, the County would be out of compliance with the law until it becomes aware of the assignment and terminates the Agreements.

 

4.                     The Agreements do not require Starlink to indemnify the County, as required by County Policy 11-07, including for intellectual property infringement claims.

•                     The County standard contract indemnity provision requires the contractor to indemnify, defend, and hold the County harmless from third party claims arising out of the acts, errors or omissions of any person. The standard contract provision for intellectual property indemnity is Contractor will indemnify, defend, and hold harmless County and its officers, employees, agents and volunteers, from any and all third party claims, costs (including without limitation reasonable attorneys’ fees), and losses for infringement of any United States patent, copyright, trademark or trade secret (Intellectual Property Rights) by any goods or services.

•                     Potential Impact:  Starlink is not required to defend, indemnify, or hold the County harmless from any claims, including indemnification for claims arising from Starlink’s negligence or intentional acts and intellectual property infringement. If the County is sued for any claim, including intellectual property infringement based on its use of Starlink’s software or services, the County may be solely liable for the costs of defense and damages, which could exceed the total amount of the Agreements.

 

5.                     The County is required to indemnify Starlink against all claims arising under the Agreements and the County’s use of the service, including the County’s breach of the Agreements, violation of the Acceptable Use Policy by the County’s users, negligence, reckless, or intentionally wrongful acts by the County or any user of the County’s account.

•                     The County’s standard contract does not include any indemnification or defense by the County of a contractor.

•                     Potential Impact:  By agreeing to indemnify Starlink, the County could be contractually waiving the protection of sovereign immunity or other statutory immunities. Claims that may otherwise be barred against the County, time limited, or expense limited could be brought against Starlink without such limitations and the County would be responsible to reimburse Starlink for costs, expenses, and damages, which could exceed the total amount of the Agreements.

 

6.                     The Agreements do not require Starlink to meet the County’s insurance standards as required pursuant to County Policy 11-07.

•                     County Policy requires contractors to carry appropriate insurance at limits and under conditions determined by the County’s Risk Management Department and set forth in the County standard contract.

•                     Potential Impact:  The County has no assurance that Starlink will be financially responsible for claims that may arise from the County’s use of the service, which could result in expenses to the County that exceed the total amount of the Agreements.

 

7.                     Starlink limits its aggregate maximum liability to the County to the total amount paid by the County to Starlink in the six months preceding the claim, without any exemptions.

•                     The County standard contract does not include a limitation of liability.

•                     Potential Impact:  Claims could exceed the liability cap and the amount of the Agreements leaving the County financially liable for the excess.

 

8.                     Starlink provides the service “AS IS” without any warranty, places the sole risk of use on the County, and specifically states that the services are not suited, and not intended as a mission-critical or safety-of-life service.

•                     There is no warranty requirement in the County standard contract. The County expects its vendors and service providers to fully warrant the products and services they provide to the County.

•                     Potential Impact:  The County’s use of the service is solely at its own risk.

 

ITD recommends approval of the SpaceX template agreements associated with the Starlink service and software licenses to maintain compliance and allow the County and its affiliated agencies to receive more viable and robust internet services, where traditional internet services are not feasible due to infrastructure limitations, cost, or other connectivity challenges.

 

PROCUREMENT

The SpaceX template agreements are the result of a non-competitive procurement. The Starlink services have the ability to provide internet services in remote or infrastructure challenged locations of the County and its affiliated agencies without the traditional infrastructure typically needed. Starlink provides high-speed satellite internet with low latency connection and no data caps. Other satellite internet providers presently cap data utilization. Additionally, as Starlink continues to develop and launch additional satellites, it is possible that performance and latency may continue to improve, and the County and its affiliated agencies may derive benefits from these enhancements. The Purchasing Department concurs with the recommendation of a non-competitive procurement of Starlink satellite-based internet service and software from SpaceX. The County and its affiliated agencies are expansive and comprised of remote, or infrastructure challenged areas that could benefit from this type of service. The SpaceX template agreements, including non-standard terms, will be used to accompany future purchase orders to be approved, as necessary, per County Policy 11-04 Procurement of Goods, Supplies, Equipment and Services.

 

REVIEW BY OTHERS

This item has been reviewed by County Counsel (Bonnie Uphold, Supervising Deputy County Counsel, 387-5455) on August 11, 2023; Purchasing (Tevan Stremel, Buyer, 387-2098) on August 14, 2023; Risk Management (Victor Tordesillas, Director, 386-8623) on August 17, 2023; Finance (Ivan Ramirez, Administrative Analyst, 387-4020) on September 18, 2023; and County Finance and Administration (Paloma Hernandez-Barker, Deputy Executive Officer, 387-5423) on September 19, 2023.