Legislation Details

File #: 3362   
Type: Consent Status: Passed
File created: 12/7/2020 Department: County Counsel
On agenda: 12/15/2020 Final action: 12/15/2020
Subject: Agreement with Reed Smith LLP for Specialized Legal Services and Waiver of Conflict of Interest
Attachments: 1. CON-Reed Smith Legal Svcs, 2. Item #37 Executed BAI, 3. 20-1250 Executed Contract

REPORT/RECOMMENDATION TO THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS

OF THE COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO

AND RECORD OF ACTION

 

December 15, 2020

 

FROM

MICHELLE D. BLAKEMORE, County Counsel 

         

SUBJECT                      

Title                     

Agreement with Reed Smith LLP for Specialized Legal Services and Waiver of Conflict of Interest

End

 

RECOMMENDATION(S)

Recommendation

1.                     Approve Agreement with Reed Smith LLP for specialized legal services in connection with insurance recovery relating to the Chino Airport volatile organic compound plume located generally in the City of Chino at the County’s Chino Airport in response to Cleanup and Abatement Order No. R8-2017-0011 (Four votes required).

2.                     Authorize the County Counsel or Chief Assistant County Counsel to amend Exhibit A to the Agreement to change or add attorneys, paralegals or other legal staff as needed.

3.                     Approve Waiver of Conflict of Interest that approves the waiver of an actual conflict of interest arising out of Reed Smith LLP’s representation of the County of San Bernardino pursuant to the Agreement and Reed Smith LLP’s representation of a party adverse to the County of San Bernardino.

4.                     Authorize the County Counsel or Chief Assistant County Counsel to execute the Waiver of Conflict of Interest.

(Presenter: Michelle D. Blakemore, County Counsel, 387-5455)

Body

 

COUNTY AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER GOALS & OBJECTIVES

Operate in a Fiscally-Responsible and Business-Like Manner.

 

FINANCIAL IMPACT

Legal services for this Agreement will be paid at a rate of $625 to $950 for partners, $425 to $545 for associates, and $355 for paralegals.  Reed Smith LLP (Reed Smith) will also be reimbursed for any consultants and experts retained for the services provided.  The cost of this Agreement is not anticipated to exceed $1,000,000 for the current fiscal year and will be funded by the Litigation Reserve and paid from the Litigation 2020-21 Budget [1340001000].  Although the litigation is anticipated to span up to four years, the total litigation costs under this Agreement are unknown at this time, and are dependent upon the necessity to engage in litigation with the County’s insurers, and the duration of any such litiation.  However, it is estimated that the specialized legal services for this Agreement may cost up to $6 million.  Requested budget adjustments to fund future costs of this litigation will be included on any future quarterly countywide budget report presented to the Board of Supervisors for approval.

 

BACKGROUND INFORMATION

Beginning in 1990, the Regional Water Quality Control Board - Santa Ana Region (Water Board) has issued several cleanup and abatement orders (CAOs) concerning groundwater contamination beneath or near the County-owned Chino Airport. 

 

During 2016 and 2017, the County prepared a Feasibility Study to identify and evaluate options to properly mitigate environmental impacts from past operations and historic activities at the Chino Airport. On January 11, 2017, the Water Board issued Cleanup and Abatement Order No. R8-2017-0011, which superseded the previous order, and which continued the requirements for the County to complete the groundwater investigation and added a new reporting requirement. The Final Feasibility Study, dated May 2017, recommended a groundwater pump-and-treat system be put in place to provide hydraulic containment of groundwater contamination utilizing groundwater extraction wells both onsite and offsite of the Chino Airport. In addition, it was recommended that an extensive groundwater monitoring program be put in place to monitor progress in the reduction of contaminant levels. Based upon the Final Feasibility Study, a Remedial Action Plan, redesignated as an Interim Remedial Action Plan, was prepared proposing implementation of the pump-and-treat system, in coordination with the Chino Desalter Authority. On January 29, 2019 (Item No. 24) the Board of Supervisors (Board) approved the Interim Remedial Action Plan and related California Environmental Quality Act documents. The Interim Remedial Action Plan was approved by the Water Board on November 4, 2020.

 

The groundwater pump and treat system is being jointly implemented under an agreement with the Chino Desalter Authority. The initial and annual ongoing cost of operations and maintenance are estimated to be $24.5 million to $32 million over a 30-year period, up to an estimated $39.5 million to $52 million for a 50-year period.  An additional $13.5 million is anticipated for the costs related to real property acquisition, design, permitting and construction of additional required County extraction wells and associated conveyances.  In the event replenishment water is necessary, the County may see an increase of up to $1.2 million annually.

 

The County is currently receiving reimbursement from the County’s insurer, Insurance Company of the State of Pennsylvania/American International Group, for investigation and remediation costs based upon a prior settlement agreement with the insurer.  However, it is anticipated that this insurer will dispute the County’s claim for continued coverage under the applicable policies.  Retaining outside counsel that specializes in insurance recovery is essential in order to assist the County with the process of ensuring maximum recovery from the insurer.  Approval of Recommendation No.1 will allow the County to utilize the services of Reed Smith LLP, a law firm that has the specialized skills, knowledge, experience and expertise in the area of insurance recovery needed to effectively assist, advise, litigate and otherwise represent the County in its recovery efforts for the period of December 15, 2020 through December 14, 2025.  Approval of Recommendation No.2 will allow County Counsel to change or add additional legal staff to the Agreement as needed.

 

Reed Smith LLP has identified a conflict of interest from its representation of Blue Cross of California dba Anthem Blue Cross and Anthem Blue Cross Life and Health Insurance Company (Blue Shield) in connection with an action filed by the County entitled County of San Bernardino dba Arrowhead Regional Medical Center v. Blue Cross of California dba Anthem Blue Cross, et al. Case No. CIVDS1723565.  This action involves various alleged underpayments for certain medical services.  The Blue Shield matter is unrelated to the legal services to be provided to the County regarding the insurance recovery related to Chino Airport.  No information received or expected to be received by Reed Smith LLP in the course of its representation regarding the Chino matter is material to its representation in the Blue Shield matter.  Appropriate ethical screens have been instituted by the firm to ensure that no confidential information pertaining to the County will be shared with Blue Cross or in its representation of Blue Cross.  Additionally, Reed Smith LLP’s attorneys and staff working on the Blue Shield matter will not perform any work, discuss or have access to documents or information related to the Chino matter.  Similarly, Reed Smith LLP’s attorneys and staff working on the Chino matter will not perform any work, discuss or have access to documents or information related to the Blue Shield matter.

 

County Counsel has reviewed the Waiver of Conflict of Interest and believes that as a result of the ethical walls in place, Reed Smith LLP will minimize the risk of prejudice to the County in its representation of the County on the Chino Airport insurance recovery matter.

 

PROCUREMENT

On August 12, 2020, County Counsel released a Request for Proposal to 17 law firms.  Six law firms submitted a proposal, as follows:

 

Name

Location

Anderson Kill

New York, New York

Keesal, Young & Logan

Long Beach, California

Reed Smith

Los Angeles, California

WilmerHale

San Francisco, California

Irell & Manella

Newport Beach, California

Earth & Water Law Group

Washington, D.C.

 

An evaluation committee comprised of representatives from County Counsel, Risk Management, and Department of Airports reviewed the proposals and selected three firms for interviews. Reed Smith LLP was selected as the law firm that meets the best interest of the County based on their experience with representing insureds and their understanding of the County’s needs. 

 

Pursuant to Title 1, Division 2, Chapter 19, Section 12.1908 of the County Code, County Counsel is authorized to select and retain through a purchase order, specialized counsel for a particular matter not to exceed $200,000 per fiscal year. Contracts for services in excess of that amount require Board of Supervisors’ approval. 

 

REVIEW BY OTHERS

This item has been reviewed by County Counsel (Kristina M. Robb, Supervising Deputy County Counsel on November 20, 2020; Purchasing (Bruce Cole, Supervising Buyer, 387-2148) on November 30, 2020; Finance (Carl Lofton, Administrative Analyst, 387-5404) on December 1, 2020 and County Finance and Administration (Robert Saldana, Deputy Executive Officer, 387-5423) on December 1, 2020.

 

#2LT6582.02