REPORT/RECOMMENDATION TO THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
OF SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY
AND RECORD OF ACTION
April 25, 2023
FROM
TOM BUNTON, County Counsel
SUBJECT
Title
Agreements with Cipriani & Werner, P.C. for Specialized Legal Services and Ankura Consulting Group, LLC for Consulting Services
End
RECOMMENDATION(S)
Recommendation
1. Ratify approval of Agreement with Cipriani & Werner, P.C. at hourly rates between $100 to $325 for specialized legal services in connection with a network disruption for the contract period effective April 7, 2023, until terminated by either party.
2. Ratify approval of Agreement with Ankura Consulting Group, LLC and Cipriani & Werner, P.C. for specialized consulting services in connection with a network disruption in amounts as authorized by County Policy for the contract period effective April 7, 2023, through the conclusion of services or termination by either party.
3. Delegate authority to the Chief Executive Officer or the County Counsel to approve revisions to the Statements of Work not-to-exceed an aggregate amount of $250,000, for the contract with Ankura Consulting Group, LLC and Cipriani & Werner, P.C.
4. Direct the Clerk of the Board of Supervisors to maintain the confidentiality of any Statements of Work for the Agreement with Ankura Consulting Group, LLC and Cipriani & Werner, P.C., pursuant to Government Code, sections 7929.210, subdivision (a) and 7927.705.
(Presenter: Tom Bunton, County Counsel, 387-5455)
Body
COUNTY AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER GOALS & OBJECTIVES
Operate in a Fiscally-Responsible and Business-Like Manner.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
Approval of this item will not result in the use of additional Discretionary General Fund (Net County Cost). Sufficient appropriation is included in the Litigation 2022-23 budget and will be included in future recommended budgets, as necessary.
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
On April 7, 2023, a County department became aware of a network disruption that affected a sector of County systems. Upon discovering this incident, the County immediately secured the network and began working with the Innovation and Technology Department and third-party forensic specialists to investigate the incident. The County has referred the incident to partnering law enforcement agencies, including the Federal Bureau of Investigations and the Department of Homeland Security. Cipriani & Werner, P.C. (Cipriani) and Ankura Consulting Group, LLC (Ankura) have been engaged to assist in the investigation into this matter.
Pursuant to California Government Code section 7929.210, subdivision (a), information security records are exempt from disclosure if, on the facts of a particular case, disclosure would reveal vulnerabilities to attack, or would otherwise increase the potential for an attack on a local agency’s information technology system. Government Code section 7927.705 also exempts disclosure of attorney-client privileged communications. Therefore, the recommendation is to direct the Clerk of the Board of Supervisors to maintain confidentiality of any Statements of Work in the Agreement with Ankura and Cipriani.
The Cipriani agreement (Contract) omits certain County standard contract terms. The omitted terms include the following:
1. The Contract is silent on governing law.
• The County standard contract requires California governing law.
• Potential Impact: The Contract may be interpreted under the State law wherever a lawsuit is brought. Any questions, issues or claims arising under this Contract may require the County to hire outside counsel competent to advise on a particular state’s law, which may result in fees that exceed the total Contract amount.
2. There is no provision in the Contract addressing each party’s responsibility for paying attorneys’ fees arising from any dispute.
• The County standard contract requires each party to bear its own costs and attorney fees, regardless of who is the prevailing party in a dispute.
• Potential Impact: County Counsel cannot advise on, whether and to what extent, another state’s law may affect a party’s requirement to pay the prevailing party’s attorneys’ fees and costs in a legal action where no specific provision is provided in the Contract.
3. The Contract does not require Cipriani to indemnify the County.
• The County standard contract indemnity provision requires the attorneys to agree to indemnify, defend and hold harmless County and its authorized officers from claims arising out of the conduct of Attorneys.
• Potential Impact: If the County is sued for any claim, the County may be solely liable for the costs of defense and damages, which could exceed the total Contract amount. County Counsel cannot advise on whether and to what extent another state’s law may allow the County to require Cipriani to defend or indemnify it absent an express provision in the Contract.
4. The Contract does not require Cipriani to meet the County’s insurance standards as required pursuant to County Policy 11-07.
• The County Policy requires service providers to carry appropriate insurance at limits and under conditions determined by the County’s Risk Management Department and set forth in the County standard contract.
• Potential Impact: The County has no assurance that Cipriani will be financially responsible for claims that may arise from the services provided, which could result in expenses to the County that exceed the total Contract amount.
5. The term of the Contract is indefinite, beginning on April 7, 2023, until the services have been concluded or until termination by either party.
• County Policy 11-06SP does not permit indefinite term or automatically renewing contracts unless approved by the Board of Supervisors (Board).
• Potential Impact: There is no end term to the Contract and the County is indefinitely bound to the terms and conditions of the Contract until Cipriani has completed its services or either the County or Cipriani terminates the Contract.
6. There is no stated venue in the Contract.
• The County standard contract requires venue for disputes in Superior Court of California, County of San Bernardino, San Bernardino District.
• Potential Impact: Cipriani is located in Montgomery County, Pennsylvania, and this may result in additional expenses that exceed the total amount of the Contract.
The Ankura and Cipriani agreement includes Ankura’s Terms of Business (Agreement), which are Ankura’s standard commercial terms and include terms that differ from the standard County contract and omits certain County standard contract terms. The non-standard and missing terms include the following:
1. Governing law is the State of New York.
• The County standard contract requires California governing law.
• Potential Impact: The Agreement will be interpreted under New York State law. Any questions, issues or claims arising under this Agreement will require the County to hire outside counsel competent to advise on New York law, which may result in fees that exceed the total Agreement amount.
2. There is no provision in the Agreement addressing each party’s responsibility for paying attorneys’ fees.
• The County standard contract requires each party to bear its own costs and attorney fees, regardless of who is the prevailing party.
• Potential Impact: County Counsel cannot advise on, whether and to what extent, New York law may affect a party’s requirement to pay the prevailing party’s attorneys’ fees and costs in a legal action where no specific provision is provided in the Agreement.
3. The Agreement does not require Ankura to indemnify the County, as required by County Policy 11-07.
• The County standard contract indemnity provision requires the contractor to indemnify, defend, and hold County harmless from third party claims arising out of the acts, errors or omissions of any person.
• Potential Impact: Ankura is not required to defend, indemnify or hold the County harmless from any claims, including indemnification for claims arising from Ankura’s negligent or intentional acts. If the County is sued for any claim, the County may be solely liable for the costs of defense and damages, which could exceed the total Agreement amount. County Counsel cannot advise on whether and to what extent New York law may allow the County to require Ankura to defend or indemnify it absent an express provision in the Agreement.
4. The County is required to indemnify Ankura against third party claims arising out of or related the services provided by Ankura, except where a court finds that the claim resulted from Ankura’s gross negligence or willful misconduct.
• The County standard contract does not include any indemnification or defense by the County of a contractor.
• Potential Impact: By agreeing to indemnify Ankura, the County could be contractually waiving the protection of sovereign immunity. Claims that may otherwise be barred against the County, time limited, or expense limited could be brought against Ankura without such limitations and the County would be responsible to defend and reimburse Ankura for costs, expenses, and damages, which could exceed the total Agreement amount. County Counsel cannot advise on, whether and to what extent, New York law may limit or expand this Agreement term.
5. The Agreement does not require Ankura to meet the County’s insurance standards as required pursuant to County Policy 11-07.
• The County Policy requires contractors to carry appropriate insurance at limits and under conditions determined by the County’s Risk Management Department and set forth in the County standard contract.
• Potential Impact: The County has no assurance that Ankura will be financially responsible for claims that may arise from the County’s use of the software, which could result in expenses to the County that exceed the total Agreement amount.
6. Ankura’s maximum liability to the County is limited to the aggregate amount of fees received from the County pursuant to the Agreement, excluding gross negligence.
• The County standard contract does not include a limitation of liability.
• Potential Impact: Claims could exceed the liability cap and the Agreement amount leaving the County financially liable for the excess. County Counsel cannot advise on, whether and to what extent, New York law may limit or expand the exclusion of limits to the extent prohibited by applicable law.
7. Except for non-payment of fees and expenses, neither party may bring a legal claim more than one year from the date that is arose.
• The County standard contract does not include a limit on the time to bring action.
• Potential Impact: Limiting the County’s ability to bring suit to one year from the date that it arose amounts to a waiver of the Statute of Limitations for claims and shortens the period of time in which the County may file a lawsuit under the Agreement. County Counsel cannot advise on, whether and to what extent, New York law may allow parties to contractually agree to override the Statute of Limitations on claims.
8. The County will not solicit or employ contractor’s personnel who participated in the services for a period of up to one year following expiration of termination of the Agreement.
• The County standard contract does not include a non-solicitation/non-compete provision.
• Potential Impact: Hiring an Ankura employee will result in liability to the County in the amount of 100% of the employee’s annual compensation, which could exceed the total Agreement amount.
9. The term of the Agreement is indefinite, beginning on April 7, 2023, until the services have been concluded or until termination by either party.
• County Policy 11-06SP does not permit indefinite term or automatically renewing contracts unless approved by the Board.
• Potential Impact: There is no end term to the Agreement and the County is indefinitely bound to the terms and conditions of the Agreement until Ankura has completed its services or either the County or Ankura provides 14 days advanced written notice.
10. Venue is in the federal courts of the Southern District of New York or the Commercial Division of the state courts residing in the County of New York.
• The County standard contract requires venue for disputes in Superior Court of California, County of San Bernardino, San Bernardino District.
• Potential Impact: Having a venue in the County of New York may result in additional expenses that exceed the amount of the Agreement.
County Counsel recommends ratification of approval of the Cipriani Contract and the Ankura Agreement, including the non-standard terms, as Cipriani and Ankura are subject matter experts to assist with the County’s investigation.
PROCUREMENT
County Code section 12.1908 authorizes County Counsel to select and retain specialized outside legal counsel. Due to the need to quickly retain specialized legal counsel and their consultant, there was insufficient time for a competitive procurement. The Purchasing Department agrees with the non-competitive procurement for these services given the immediate need for services.
REVIEW BY OTHERS
This item has been reviewed by County Counsel (Julie Surber, Principal Assistant County Counsel, 387-5455) on April 13, 2023; Purchasing (Bruce Cole, Supervising Buyer, 387-2148) on April 13, 2023; Finance (Carl Lofton, Administrative Analyst, 387-5404) on April 13, 2023; and County Finance and Administration (Paloma Hernandez-Barker, Deputy Executive Officer, 387-5423) on April 13, 2023.