REPORT/RECOMMENDATION TO THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
OF THE COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO
AND RECORD OF ACTION
January 28, 2020
FROM
LEANNA WILLIAMS, Director, Department of Risk Management
MICHELLE D. BLAKEMORE, County Counsel, County Counsel
SUBJECT
Title
Contracts for Legal Settlement Services for Workers’ Compensation Claims Closing Pilot Project.
End
RECOMMENDATION(S)
Recommendation
Approve contracts with the following firms to provide settlement services for a six month pilot project to close workers’ compensation claims, at an hourly rate of $190 for partners and senior associates, $125 for hearing representatives, and $120 for paralegals and law clerks, with an estimated aggregate cost of $150,000, for the period of January 28, 2020 through July 31, 2020 (Four votes required).
1. Laughlin, Falbo, Levy & Moresi, LLP
2. Law Offices of Robert Wheatley, APC
3. Michael Sullivan & Associates, LLP
(Presenter: LeAnna Williams, Director, 386-8621)
Body
COUNTY AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER GOALS & OBJECTIVES
Operate in a Fiscally-Responsible and Business-Like Manner.
Improve County Government Operations.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
Approval of this item will not result in the use of additional Discretionary General Funding (Net County Cost) as these services will be paid from the Department of Risk Management’s (DRM) workers’ compensation self-insurance funds 4082 (Countywide) and 4104 (Special Districts), in accordance with contracted hourly rates. These self-insurance funds are financed by County departments and Special Districts via internal service rates annually approved by the Board of Supervisors. The estimated aggregate cost for these services, over the entire project period, is approximately $150,000; sufficient appropriation has been included in DRM’s 2019-20 budget, and will be included in the 2020-21 recommended budget.
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
DRM has managed the County’s self-insured workers’ compensation program since 1972. During that time, DRM has contracted with outside law firms to provide legal defense services for litigated workers’ compensation claims for the County, its Board Governed Special Districts and County Service Areas. DRM is conducting a workers’ compensation claims closing pilot project to determine if financial benefit exists warranting a more comprehensive claims closing project.
The purpose of this pilot project is to settle and close litigated legacy claims (for claimants that are no longer employed by the County) via compromise and release. Claims selected for this project are workers’ compensation claims with dates of loss older than two years, excluding any claims related to the December 2, 2015 incident. Contractors will be assigned a specific number of claims and are expected to evaluate each case and provide a report that contains expected potential liability and cost, settlement value and basis used to arrive at this value, and estimated legal cost. Contractor performance will be evaluated on the timeliness of deliverables and performance measurements as outlined in the Statement of Qualifications (SOQ). The DRM will analyze this information to determine if there is a significant financial benefit to the County that justifies a more comprehensive workers’ compensation claims closing project.
PROCUREMENT
On October 4, 2019, SOQ No. RMG120-RMADM-3485 was released and posted to the County’s electronic Procurement Network (e-Pro). The following 17 law firms submitted statements of qualifications and offered services for the workers’ compensation claims closing pilot project.
|
Law Firm |
Location |
|
Bradford & Barthel, LLP |
Ontario, CA |
|
Bredfeldt, Odukoya & Han, LLP |
Corona, CA |
|
Chou Law Group, LLP |
Santa Ana, CA |
|
D'Andre Law, LLP |
Oakland, CA |
|
Hallett, Emerick, Wells & Sareen, PLC |
San Bernardino, CA |
|
Karlzen Hutchinson, Inc. |
Torrance, CA |
|
Laughlin, Falbo, Levy & Moresi, LLP |
San Bernardino, CA |
|
Law Offices of Gray & Prouty, APC |
Arroyo Grande, CA |
|
Law Offices of Parker & Irwin, APC |
San Bernardino, CA |
|
Law Offices of Paul C. Herman, PLC |
Hermosa Beach, CA |
|
Law Offices of Robert Wheatley |
Tustin, CA |
|
Law Offices of Schlossberg & Umholtz, ALC |
Brea, CA |
|
Law Offices of Stacey L. Tokunaga |
Orange, CA |
|
MacDonald, Ebbing & Lloyd, LLP |
Ladera Ranch, CA |
|
Michael Sullivan & Associates |
El Segundo, CA |
|
Samuelsen, Gonzalez, Valenzuela and Brown, LLP |
Newport Beach, CA |
|
Waters & Robinson, LLP |
Diamond Bar, CA |
An evaluation panel consisting of staff from the DRM, County Counsel, San Bernardino County Transportation Authority, and California State Association of Counties - Excess Insurance Authority evaluated the SOQs and ranked them based on compliance with requirements, firm and staff qualifications, experience providing settlement services of workers’ compensation claims for public entities and offered work plan. The evaluation panel recommends awarding contracts to the three (3) highest ranking law firms. On December 11, 2019, the notice of intent to award (NOIA) was sent to all law firms that submitted an SOQ. No appeals were received.
REVIEW BY OTHERS
This item has been reviewed by County Counsel (Teresa McGowan, Principal Assistant County Counsel, 387-5283) on December 12, 2019; Purchasing Department (Michelle Churchill, Supervising Buyer, 387-2070) on December 30, 2019; Finance [Joon Cho (387-5402) and Carl Lofton (387-5404) Administrative Analyst, 387-5402) on January 10, 2020; and County Finance and Administration (Kelly Welty, Deputy Executive Officer, 387-5423) on January 10, 2020.