Legislation Details

File #: 1902   
Type: Consent Status: Passed
File created: 3/17/2020 Department: Land Use Services
On agenda: 3/24/2020 Final action: 3/24/2020
Subject: v Action to Void and Set Aside Limited Portions of the May 1, 2018, Board of Supervisors' Certification of the Environmental Impact Report for Lazer Broadcasting Facility Project
Attachments: 1. Item #30 Executed BAI

REPORT/RECOMMENDATION TO THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS

OF THE COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO

AND RECORD OF ACTION

 

March 24, 2020

 

FROM

TERRI RAHHAL, Director, Land Use Services 

         

SUBJECT                      

Title                     v

Action to Void and Set Aside Limited Portions of the May 1, 2018, Board of Supervisors’ Certification of the Environmental Impact Report for Lazer Broadcasting Facility Project

End

 

RECOMMENDATION(S)

Recommendation

Void and set aside portions of the May 1, 2018, Board of Supervisors’ certification of the sections of the Final Environmental Impact Report (State Clearinghouse No. 2008041082) relating to Agricultural and Forestry Resources, Air Quality, Cultural Resources, Greenhouse Gases, Hydrology and Water Quality, Mineral Resources, Noise, Population/Housing, Public Services, Transportation/Traffic, and Utilities and Service Systems.

(Presenter: Terri Rahhal, Director, 387-4431)

Body

 

COUNTY AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER GOALS & OBJECTIVES

Ensure Development of a Well-Planned, Balanced, and Sustainable County.

 

FINANCIAL IMPACT

Approval of this item will not result in the use of additional Discretionary General Funding (Net County Cost) as there are no financial impacts associated with this item. 

 

BACKGROUND INFORMATION

This matter is submitted to comply with a Superior Court order in Citizens for the Preservation of Rural Living v. County of San Bernardino (CIVDS1213272) involving a radio broadcasting tower and equipment shelter proposed to be built near the Wildwood State Park in the Oak Glen area.

 

As originally submitted in 2007, this application was a request to approve construction of a 140-foot tall steel lattice radio broadcast tower and a 250 square foot equipment shelter.  Through the initial review process, the tower height was reduced to 80 feet, with the equipment shelter remaining the same size (Original Project).  The County Development Code requires a Conditional Use Permit for radio broadcasting facilities in the zone where the subject site is located. The Original Project was approved by the Planning Commission on November 6, 2008, which determination was appealed by Citizens for Preservation of Rural Living (CPRL) to the Board of Supervisors (Board).  On March 3, 2009 (Item 59), the Board granted the appeal and denied the Original Project.

 

The application was revised to a 43-foot tall wooden pole (with attached hardware for it to function as a radio broadcast tower) and the equipment shelter was reduced to 100 square feet (Project).  The Planning Commission approved the Project on September 20, 2012.  CPRL again appealed the decision to the Board, which, on November 27, 2012 (Item 81), denied the appeal and approved the Project.  This approval included the Board’s adoption of a Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) for the Project under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).

 

CPRL challenged the County’s approval in the Superior Court on the basis that the adoption of the MND violated CEQA in a number of ways.  Although the Superior Court agreed with only some of CPRL’s arguments, the County was nonetheless required to revise its environmental analysis.  This ruling was upheld by the Court of Appeals.

 

An Environmental Impact Report (EIR) was prepared to address deficiencies in the environmental analysis that had been found by the Superior Court.  In order to comply with the Superior Court’s order, on April 18, 2017 (Item 84), the Board vacated its prior Project approvals and the MND.  At the same time, staff’s recommendation to certify the EIR and re-approve the Project failed to garner a majority vote.

 

At the applicant’s request, the Project application and EIR were re-submitted to the Planning Commission, which on November 9, 2017, approved the Project and certified the EIR.  CPRL appealed that decision to the Board, which on May 1, 2018 (Item 74), on a 3-2 vote, denied the appeal, certified the EIR, and approved the Project.

 

CPRL filed a supplemental challenge to this Board decision with the Superior Court based, again, on a number of arguments.  The Superior Court issued its ruling on August 1, 2019, and further clarified the ruling in a supplemental explanation issued on November 8, 2019.  The Superior Court again found most of the challenges without merit but ruled that certain portions of the EIR were inadequate.  The Superior Court ruled that rescission of the Project approvals, decertification of the entire Final EIR, preparation of a new CEQA Notice of Preparation, and revision and/or recirculation of the discussion on Geology and Soils are not required.  Thus, the County was only ordered to void and set aside limited portions of the EIR addressing:  (1) Agricultural and Forestry Resources, (2) Air Quality, (3) Cultural Resources, (4) Greenhouse Gases, (5) Hydrology and Water Quality, (6) Mineral Resources, (7) Noise, (8) Population/Housing, (9) Public Services, (10) Transportation/Traffic, and (11) Utilities and Service Systems (the Eleven Issues).

 

Assuming the applicant intends to move forward with the Project, inadequacies in the EIR as to the Eleven Issues will be remedied, and it is staff’s intent to clarify other issues to precisely conform to the Superior Court ruling.  The revisions and clarifications will be recirculated for public comment and responses will be provided to any ensuing public comments on the recirculated portions of the EIR.  The resulting environmental record will be submitted to the Board for consideration in a noticed public hearing on a date to be determined but anticipated for spring or early summer of this year.

 

Per the Superior Court order, the Project approvals need not be set aside, but are suspended and construction enjoined pending the above.

 

PROCUREMENT

N/A

 

REVIEW BY OTHERS

This item has been reviewed by (Bart Brizzee, Principal Assistant County Counsel and Jason Searles, Deputy County Counsel, 387-5455) on February 26, 2020; Finance (Kathleen Gonzalez, Administrative Analyst III, 387-5412) on February 26, 2020; County Finance and Administration (Robert Saldana, Deputy Executive Officer, 387-5423) on March 9, 2020.